Worked Examples and Optional Depth
Use these cards after the corresponding core teaching. They supply the scenario and a sample response; no external research, new account, real-world contact, or private disclosure is required. The examples are fictional teaching cases, not real measurements, medical guidance, legal rulings, financial advice, or promises of outcomes.
Two kinds of optional work
- Supplied practice: the scenario, sample response, and depth question are on this page. Allow about 15–20 minutes for one card, with paper or oral explanation. Read the card before the session; a calculator is optional for arithmetic.
- Open research prompt: a request to locate or construct missing teaching material, such as outside sources, interview records, or a real-case packet. This is not supplied instruction. A tool activity with complete steps is still supplied instruction, even when an adult must prepare the device or account. An adult must select and verify materials, arrange access, and plan additional time first. Use the supplied card instead when those materials are unavailable.
Choose depth by readiness and interest, not age alone. Learners aged 10–12 can use the core teaching without taking every technical add-on; older-learner work remains optional. The depth questions are not prerequisites for the next core week or criteria for its checkpoint.
How to use a card
- Read the scenario and ask for a reasoned answer.
- Let the learner draw, speak, sort, or write using the fictional case.
- Compare with the sample: notice the evidence and the limits, not matching wording.
- If ready, change the stated assumption using the depth question.
- If the core idea is unclear, return to the linked lesson before adding complexity. A private or paper artifact is enough.
Sample responses illustrate reasoning, not scripts to memorize or the only defensible answer to an open choice. They do not require a learner to experience or disclose the situation.
Week 1
Core lesson: Week 1: Rules We Already Follow
Supplied scenario and question: A pretend library asks visitors to walk indoors. Which purposes might the rule serve?
Illustrative response: It can reduce collisions and noise, supporting safety and shared use. One rule can serve several purposes, and its effects still need checking.
Optional depth: Revise an unclear rule while explaining whose access or needs it might affect.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 2
Core lesson: Week 2: The Island Challenge
Supplied scenario and question: A fictional island has one water tap and five families. What is missing from "Everyone do what you want"?
Illustrative response: The group needs a fair way to share access, maintain the tap, and address disputes. Rules need a reason and an accountable process.
Optional depth: Add a review route for a family excluded by the first plan.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 3
Core lesson: Week 3: From Families to Nations
Supplied scenario and question: Compare a family choosing dinner with a town maintaining a road. Why are they different systems?
Illustrative response: Both coordinate people, but the town serves a larger public with formal powers and responsibilities. A family analogy does not define every government power.
Optional depth: Name one useful similarity and one limit of the analogy.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 4
Core lesson: Week 4: The Social Contract
Supplied scenario and question: A fictional child breaks a playground rule. Do they lose safety or fair treatment?
Illustrative response: No. A proportionate response can address conduct while rights and protections remain. Responsibilities do not purchase rights.
Optional depth: Explain how an adult can enforce a rule without treating dignity or access to learning as a reward.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 5
Core lesson: Week 5: The Constitution — Our Founding Agreement
Supplied scenario and question: A pretend club charter says who may make rules and how to change them. How is that different from a snack rule?
Illustrative response: The charter sets the structure and limits of authority; the snack rule governs one activity within that structure.
Optional depth: Add an amendment process and explain why a leader cannot silently change it alone.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 6
Core lesson: Week 6: Three Branches, One Government
Supplied scenario and question: In a simplified town model, one body makes rules, another carries them out, and another reviews disputes. Name the functions.
Illustrative response: They are legislative, executive, and judicial functions in this model. Actual local structures vary, so the classroom labels are not a map of every town.
Optional depth: Describe a check between two functions and a way that check could fail.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 7
Core lesson: Week 7: How a Law Is Made
Supplied scenario and question: A fictional council proposes longer library hours. What steps make the change more than a suggestion?
Illustrative response: Discuss the proposal, hear affected people, follow the authorized decision process, and arrange staffing/resources if approved. A vote alone does not staff the library.
Optional depth: Separate making the rule from carrying it out and measuring its effect.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 8
Core lesson: Week 8: Checks and Balances
Supplied scenario and question: A fictional repair rule exists, but a reported broken rail stays broken. Has the institution succeeded?
Illustrative response: No. The rule and report did not produce the needed implementation. Adults must protect users and seek a responsible office and follow-up evidence.
Optional depth: Contrast an accessible complaint route with one that excludes affected people; do not promise that one complaint guarantees repair.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 9
Core lesson: Week 9: Elections and Voting
Supplied scenario and question: In a fictional vote, A gets 6, B gets 4, and 2 eligible people cannot reach the voting place. What do the counts tell you?
Illustrative response: A has more of the 10 counted votes, but the access barrier matters to the process. Winning a count does not prove participation was fair.
Optional depth: Propose an accessible route for the next vote while keeping voter choice private.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 10
Core lesson: Week 10: Your Town, Your Rules
Supplied scenario and question: A fictional noisy-crossing problem appears beside a local road. Who should the learner identify first?
Illustrative response: The office responsible for that road and crossing, using verified local information with adult help. It may not be the same office in every place.
Optional depth: Draft a factual request with location and observations, without posting private identifying information.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 11
Core lesson: Week 11: Schools, Libraries, and Public Services
Supplied scenario and question: A fictional library has a limited budget and requests for books, access improvements, and longer hours. What makes planning civic?
Illustrative response: It weighs shared needs, resources, and who can use the service. Decisions should be explainable and open to affected people’s input.
Optional depth: Choose one information gap, such as actual demand or access barriers, before recommending an allocation.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 12
Core lesson: Week 12: Seeing Government in Action
Supplied scenario and question: A supplied meeting record lists a proposal, two comments, and a postponed decision. Can you say the rule passed?
Illustrative response: No. The record shows discussion and postponement, not approval. A meeting agenda is also not evidence of the final action.
Optional depth: Write a neutral summary separating proposal, evidence, decision, and unresolved questions.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 13
Core lesson: Week 13: Diplomacy and Trade
Supplied scenario and question: Two fictional regions need to share river information. What can diplomacy do?
Illustrative response: Representatives can exchange information and negotiate an agreement. Different interests may remain, and an agreement needs implementation.
Optional depth: Add a dispute or review step without assuming one region can command the other.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 14
Core lesson: Week 14: Solving Problems Across Borders
Supplied scenario and question: An invented river agreement asks each region to report monthly water readings. One sends none. What failed?
Illustrative response: The promised reporting did not occur. Check why, who can help, and what follow-up the agreement allows; signing alone was insufficient.
Optional depth: Distinguish a capacity problem from a refusal when the evidence does not yet establish which occurred.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 15
Core lesson: Week 15: Spotting Problems Worth Solving
Supplied scenario and question: A fictional park has a sign people cannot read from the path. Define the problem without deciding the solution first.
Illustrative response: Users cannot reliably find the information from the path. A larger sign, a closer location, or another access format could help.
Optional depth: Name affected users and one observation that would help compare solutions.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 16
Core lesson: Week 16: Research and Plan Your Proposal
Supplied scenario and question: Plan a fictional sign proposal using three observations, a cost estimate, and the responsible office. What else matters?
Illustrative response: Check whether observations are comparable, label the estimate, and seek affected users’ input. A proposal needs an authorized path and resources.
Optional depth: Identify one assumption to verify before presenting the plan as ready to implement.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 17
Core lesson: Week 17: Build Your Case
Supplied scenario and question: A trial sign helped 4 of 5 fictional readers find the path. Write a limited supporting claim.
Illustrative response: "Four of five readers in this small trial found the path. We should test more access needs and conditions before claiming it works for everyone."
Optional depth: Add one likely objection and a concrete response that stays within the evidence.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.
Week 18
Core lesson: Week 18: Citizen Showcase
Supplied scenario and question: Present the fictional proposal without contacting real officials. What demonstrates civic learning?
Illustrative response: Explain the problem, evidence, responsible institution, affected people, plan, limits, and next review step. Real-world influence is not required to show understanding.
Optional depth: Offer a drawing or private explanation; do not grade learners on public speaking or whether an institution agrees.
Facilitator check: Ask which stated fact or assumption supports the explanation. If that link is missing, model it with the sample and invite a second explanation. Assess reasoning and limits, not speed, exact wording, or personal experience.